Tutoring a Baby to Grow into an 'English Gentleman' – Does It Justify the Investment?

Child education concept
The company behind the advertisement states that what seems like "extravagance or peculiarity" is actually "intentional investment in early instruction".

"A household residing in North London seeks an extraordinary and qualified instructor to support their most junior child on his initial journey to becoming an English gentleman."

Upon seeing this listing, you might readily overlook the term "beginning" as mere figurative language.

Yet, it might be the crucial element of this distinctive position posting, as it attempts to recruit a tutor for a 12-month-old.

Hundreds of submissions have already been received since the unnamed family posted their search for the £180,000 per year tutor, who needs to be "someone very special".

During the past few weeks, the advert has attracted attention throughout the press, with many asking why?

Forward-Thinking Method

Adam Caller, head and founder of a global tutoring firm, which is supporting the family in their quest, explained that notwithstanding first scepticism, he found the concept "far sighted", and "innovative".

When he spoke with the family, he said they recognized the unconventional nature of their request, and how young their son is.

Nevertheless, they clarified that they "didn't want to wait any longer" to hire a tutor, as they had held off until their elder sibling was five, and by that point "cultural influence had already become established".

What precisely does the family refer to by "cultural leaning"?

It's "everything", the expert answered. "The way you eat, the way you speak".

He stated the firstborn had picked up "very nuanced, non-verbal cues" from the family, and had taken on their cultural norms. The family told Adam they did not want the same situation to happen again with their new baby.

The plan: To hire a British tutor, who needs to speak with standard English accent, to guide the baby from the very start.

Tutoring discussion
Tutors International state the listing has initiated a wider conversation about how households view schooling, elitism and the function of cultural environment in education.

Osmotic Learning

"A great deal of the learning at the outset here is rather acquired indirectly," stated the expert.

It's via this osmosis that the family are expecting the child will adopt the British traits they wish to impart.

The consultant explained the tutor needed to be someone who studied at "the appropriate educational institutions – the same kinds of schools as the family aspire to send their son to".

"The tutor just has to be the appropriate candidate, they'll be carrying out things they don't even know they're doing, effortlessly," he added.

Expense Not a Factor

The family informed Adam the successful candidate should ideally also have understanding of or interest in horse riding, skiing, artistic pursuits and music so as to inspire the child in a wide range of hobbies.

More than that though, he explained the family desired the tutor to sign up the child on a variety of courses so the child would be "pony-riding and picking up an instrument by the time they are around three years old".

In the family's view, assisting their son become a "UK sophisticate" will lead to success and create opportunities.

"For all the pros and cons of that, because it's definitely a social class indicator," he notes.

But, in spite of all this tutelage in "UK identity", would the child absorb alleged cultural leaning from the international family he is raised by in any case?

"Absolutely", answered he. "They understand this might not succeed, but they've simply adopted the view of, 'let's give it a go and we should start as early as we can', because the cost of it is irrelevant," he said.

Impractical

Several in the education sector who share these concerns.

An education leader, head and founder of Blue Education, who provides private tutors, wrote that "the process of becoming bicultural, or in fact, discovering oneself, is something that must be grown into, not designed."

Peter explained that he had emigrated from the Far East to the Britain at the age of 7 years old, and had been raised understanding and practicing dual heritages. He went on to be educated at a prestigious UK institution.

Peter Cui portrait
The educator was the pioneer born in the People's Republic of China to be selected to the position of Treasurer of the Cambridge Union.

"The concept that an individual can serve as a embodiment of English culture, an individual who can somehow impart the qualities of a British gentleman upon a 12-month-old child, seems to me naive and unfeasible," he stated.

"Based on my background, engaging a quintessentially British tutor from infancy will will not necessarily produce the result they want.

"I never had such a figure, and yet I have been lucky enough to live many of the experiences they aspire for their son."

He added: "The fact is, personal identity should not be dictated from the outside influences; it must be chosen, and it must originate internally."

Acquiring Englishness

Of course, English culture is something the CEO believes can be instructed – and commercialized.

"In my view the reality that the international society holds us in this regard is something that we should be cherishing|valuing|appreciating

Spencer Pope
Spencer Pope

Lena Voss is a tech journalist and UX designer with a passion for human-centered design.